Coaching a FIRST LEGO League Challenge Team on the Innovation Project

Video of Workshop Held on September 14, 2020

Load video

YouTube

YouTube might collect personal data. Privacy Policy

ContinueDismiss

Outline of Workshop

Famous FIRST LEGO League Innovative Solutions

• 3D printed hands for children
• Washable barcodes for produce to make sure food is fresh
• Baby temperature monitor for car seats
• Smart cane for visually impaired, using an ultrasonic sensor
• Easy grip spoon for seniors and individuals with diseases like Parkinson’s
• Cigarette butt legislation in Washington state

Importance of Innovation Project

• Scientific process vs Engineering process
• Science asks questions, and looks for answers
• Engineering identifies problems and develops solutions
• Engineering process is often more practical in everyday life
• Project provides opportunity to engage in the engineering process
• Choose a problem
• Research what has already be done
• Develop a new or improved solution
• Present the solution
• It counts 25% towards overall tournament awards

Scientific Method versus Engineering Method

Scientific method can be	Engineering method can be
State a hypothesis	Identify a real-world problem
Research what is already known	Research and analyze existing solutions
Design an experiment	Identify possible improvements or new solutions
Collect data	Develop prototype(s)
Analyze data	Pick a solution
Make a conclusion	Get feedback
Identify future research	Refine the solution
Publish	Communicate and deploy

Engineering Design Process

This Workshop

• Presents a process that your team can use.
• Shares more ideas than they’ll actually be able use.
• Allows you to customize to age and experience of team.
• Provides starting points for their creativity.

It’s the kids’ project!

• Don’t get so attached to working the project that it becomes more your project than the team’s project.
• Judges will ask how the team came up with their idea.
• Kids need to do the work; not the adults!
• Parents can play a supporting role.

Additional Things To Keep in Mind

• Important to have an accurate and correct understanding of the challenge.
• Make sure team understands what kinds of problems are allowed by the challenge.
• Kids may initially think of problems they have been studying in school and solve something outside the scope of the challenge.
• Kids (like many adults) have a tendency to jump to solution space, without a clear and understood problem statement.

The Innovative Project Rubric

• Identify: Clearly define a problem and research it well.
• Design: Generate innovative ideas independently before selecting and planning which to to develop.
• Create: Develop an original idea or build on an existing one with a prototype model or drawing to represent a solution.
• Iterate: Share ideas, collecting feedback and including improvements in the solution.
• Communicate: Share a creative and effective presentation of current solution and its impact on users.

Identify a Problem

• Consider annual theme regarding types of problems and the constraints it imposes.
• Watch the annual videos
  • Teaser
  • Kickoff
• Answer the sample questions from the challenge materials.
• Encourage personal interactions with the theme.
• If you already know an expert or a professional in the field, what are they working on that relates?
• What are local universities doing in the area of the theme?
• Consider anything your team already knows, or is already interested in with regards to the theme.

Brainstorming to Choose a Problem

• Round 1: Each team member suggests a “crazy” idea
• Round 2: Build on the initial suggestions
• Assign a team member to be the recorder
• high-tech or low-tech options, make sure the record is shared afterwards
• Team members vote to select the top 2 - 4 ideas
• Make sure the final ideas are clearly stated
• Begin research on the final ideas
• Reconvene
• Review the research
• Choose one problem to pursue

Example from a previous season

Trash Trek: reduce, reuse, recycle Dive Deep: Research the possible problem statements

• What is already being done to address the problem – why aren’t they working or working well?
• Has someone solved a similar problem, will that work for your team’s problem?
• Are there other possible solutions, but they aren’t being used? Why or why not? How could your team change that?

Dive Deep

• What is already being done to address the problem – why aren’t they working or working well?
• Has someone solved a similar problem, will that work for your team’s problem?
• Are there other possible solutions, but they aren’t being used? Why or why not?
• How could your team change that?
• What is being developed, but isn’t finished yet? Can you help or suggest changes based on your research?
• Is there a group that is excluded by existing solutions, can your team help them to be included?
• Keep track of sources and give credit.
• Teams can interview experts during this step and later.

Contacting professionals

• Opportunity for kids to interact with adults
• Kids realize the impact and importance and relevance of local engineering.
• Opportunity to introduce FLL to the professional community
• On site visits are best
• seeing where engineers work
• probably not feasible during pandemic
• Remember to thank everyone the team works with.

Brainstorm Possible Solutions

• Brainstorm possible solutions
• Solutions can be
• physical
• social
• legislative
• virtual
• What technologies are needed?
• Are they currently available?
• Star Trek style solutions are still welcome, but they are a tough sell with Oregon judges.
• Know your stuff!
• Select finalists for further research

What is Innovative?

• Can be something completely new; or
• Using an existing solution in a new way.
• Be careful: The judges need to see how this is a new way too!
• Improving something that already exists.
• Improving access to or awareness of an existing solution.
• Making an existing solution easier to use.

Research Candidate Solutions

• What about team’s solution is new or different?
• Why is it not already in place?
• If your solution already exists in some form,
• Is there a problem with the current version?
• Can you design a solution to that problem?
• How much would your solution cost? Who pays for it?

Example: How can the problem of plastic bags be solved?

• Solution: Turn plastic bags into rope
  • Some technologies to do this already exist.
  • Next steps: Cost analysis, efficiency improvements. Is the process environmentally sound?
• Solution: Pass legislation to ban the use of single-use plastic bags.
  • Already in place in many municipalities
  • Next steps: Understand what other have done, consider improving and how to make it more widely adopted.

• Solution: Plastic bag collection bins in parks.
  • Already present in many parks
  • Next steps: Are they being used? What happens to the bags once they are collected?

Research and Consult Experts About Solution

• Who else is working on this problem?
• Universities
• Professionals
• Businesses
• Public groups
• Who is in a position to use your solution?
• Your experts will have opinions and knowledge.
• Listen to their criticism.
• Be prepared to think critically about your solution given their feedback.
• Does your team need to make changes?
• How would your team address a similar criticism in the future?
• Share this information with the judges.

Advisors and Potential Users

• Advisors can help team consider
  • how their idea could be implemented
  • what the challenges may be
  • how much it would cost
• Potential users can help refine the idea
  • Who might use the idea?
  • How could the team reach them?
• Consider surveying advisors or potential users
  • Can be done using a form or by interviewing
  • Use both multiple-choice and open-ended questions

Solution Research Considerations

• Remember the basics of a journal article:
• Who, What, Where, Why, and How?
• You should know all of this for your solution.
• Nothing in life is free, everything has a cost
• What would your solution cost.
• A good solution with a high cost needs to be rationalized as to why it is better than a lower cost solution.

Fact or Fiction?

• Basics of research
  • There are a lot of ideas out there
  • Especially about problems that impact people directly
• It is important to be able to tell
  • what is a fact
  • what is opinion
  • what is fiction

Create a Prototype or Drawing

• When possible create a prototype and test it!
• Use cardboard, wood or something else.
• If team can’t build a prototype they can create a drawing.
• Prototype or drawing should
• Show solution
• Show how it will work
• Identify challenges

Using Prototype or Model

• Drawing or building focuses the kids attention
• One type of prototype is a cell phone app
• For Android phones consider App Inventor
• appinventor.mit.edu
• A prototype doesn’t need to be complete or polished
• A concept prototype or model
• Illustrates team’s idea without actually implementing it
• Could be
• diagrams
• illustrations
• storyboard
• Another alternative: Taking an existing product and modifying it
• Test the prototype in some way: Function, usefulness, ..

Styrofoam to Glue for School

• Existing Solution: Orange Oil dissolves Styrofoam and turns it into glue.
• The team learned this in their online research and tested it in their homes.
• They even tested the strength of the glue.
• Possible Innovative Solution: Two-Parts
• Create a mixing device for making the glue AND
• An app so that people
• can find schools that own the mixing devices AND
• can collect Styrofoam to make their own glue for schools.
• Additional considerations:
• Adjusting the proportions or formula to make the glue perform better in certain circumstances.
• There will often be trade offs.

Developing the Presentation

• Can be any format that covers all the criteria, including:
  • Formal presentation
  • Skit
  • Anything creative
• Remember that the medium should not distract from the message
• If there is a prototype:
  • Show and tell
  • Use a skit to show how it would be used
  • Make it personal and fun
  • Whole team participation
  • Practice with a live audience if possible

Sharing your work

• Beyond presentations at school
• Present to experts in the field
• Share with populations that could be impacted
  • Who uses it?
  • Who benefits?
• Gather feedback to make improvements this season or later for a future version

Judging

Cover all the criteria on the rubric!

• Identify: Clearly define a problem and research it well.
• Design: Generate innovative ideas independently before selecting and planning which to to develop.
• Create: Develop an original idea or build on an existing one with a prototype model or drawing to represent a solution.
• Iterate: Share ideas, collecting feedback and including improvements in the solution.
• Communicate: Share a creative and effective presentation of current solution and its impact on users.

You will have 5 minutes to creatively share all of this in a memorable way!

Videos of Project Presentations

• Robation Project Performance at Oregon Championship

• Impressive presentation from a past season